Score: 4

"good idea"

submission: clickplay2

date: November 19, 2009

but the biggest flaw is level 21. I understand how to beat it, but laptop people can't, so I give it a 4

Score: 4

"well..."

submission: Vorago

date: July 25, 2009

I give it points on the gameplay and art (at times, it was just meh...)

The Vioce acting was very...bad. I think it would have sounded better if it was more natural. During the cutscense, I thought I was watching an elementary school play. It could have done without the overacting.

The minigames could have been taken out too, they only detracted form the fun factor.

The lack of plot development was a big problem for me, it seems like you went straight to the supernatural, so there wasn't much to go on to. It's almost like being told the end of a movie before you watch it.

I know the mist was an inspiration for this, but it seems like a watered down version of it, not much originality to it. The only thing that made The Mist a great movie to me was the ending, when they finally escape and then when they run out of gas, the main character ends up having to kill everyone but himself, then when he is the last one alive, help finally arrives. That's what made it a good ending, the tragic and defeated feeling of it.

It seemed kind of rushed to me, like we are just to assume certain things happen. The end was also really disappointing, made me feel like I just wasted time.

All in all, it was just meh.

Score: 2

"ugh"

submission: What have we done?

date: July 22, 2009

I think that kind of mentality is going to make the world end. Grow up, if you honestly feel that way, then do something about it.

I'll just rate the flash though, fast slide show of images set to a crappy recording of moonlight sonata. Not original, you should put more effort into it by maybe getting some pictures with background stories, or better yet make your own drawing/story.

Score: 5

"Sounds okay"

submission: B-Flat Harmonic Progression

date: November 22, 2009

It would be better if you would have made an actual melody out of it, instead of just going up and down the scale. It gets really repetitive, and boring pretty quickly.

Score: 7

"it was ok"

submission: Solus- Duet in C Minor

date: June 21, 2009

It sounded uninspired to me, though that's just my opinion, and I don't really hear any classical elements in this piece, another disappointment. I think it gets pretty repetitive and boring. I also think it sounds like a techno/electronica genre, but with a piano instead of the synths.

A good composition, but I don't like it that much, so I'll grade on effort.

Score: 7

"wel..."

submission: Brando - Pure & Tainted

date: June 19, 2009

I see this as a common misconception here on newgrounds. Just because you used a piano, doesn't mean it's classical. To me it sounds like you took a electronic genre song and added a piano. The second half was the only thing I think could barley pass as "neo-classical".

The song was ok, but it's the same thing as electronica music, which gets kind of repetitive, only with a paino.